Changes between Version 5 and Version 6 of AuthorChecklist


Ignore:
Timestamp:
04/28/15 14:31:20 (10 years ago)
Author:
joe
Comment:

--

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified

  • AuthorChecklist

    v5 v6  
    11= Checklist for Authors of Science Articles in Solar Physics = 
    22 
    3 TODO: clarify which of these apply to raw data vs. intermediary data vs. final results / published data.  Also, try to clean this up so it's more cronological : (1) where you got the data from, (2) how you reduced the data, (3) other processing applied. 
     3== Goals : == 
     4 
     5* Ensure that research is reproducible. 
     6* Track information that might affect your analysis 
     7* Make it easier for others to retrieve the data that you used. 
     8* Allow data archives & software authors to find who's using their work, so they can get continued funding. 
    49 
    510== Background: == 
    … …  
    914* [http://sdac.virtualsolar.org/catalogs/catalog_checklist.txt "Catalog Checklist" (for people publishing catalogs)] 
    1015* [http://www.agu.org/pubs/authors/policies/data_policy.shtml "AGU Data Policy"] 
    11          
    12  
    13 == Goal : == 
    14         Ensure that research is reproducable. 
    15  
    16 === Secondary goal: === 
    17         Provide attribution for the data/archives, and software or other tools, so they can justify their continued funding. 
    18  
    1916 
    2017== Policy : == 
    21 * Data used in articles should be made publicly available. 
     18 
     19* Data used in articles should be made publicly available by the time of publication. 
    2220* If the data is not already available from an archive, it should be included as a supplement to the article. 
    2321* Observations should be sufficiently described to allow reviewers or other scientists to easily verify the article's claims. 
    … …  
    5856----- 
    5957 
    60 == Author Checklist == 
     58== The Checklist == 
    6159 
    6260* Have I described the data that was used in this research? 
    … …  
    7674                    * AEC vs. non AEC for SDO/AIA. 
    7775                *       If using cutouts from the original data 
    78                     * eg, "200 arcsec patch centered on AR10943" vs. "200 arcsec wide by 400 arcsec high centered on ... xSun, ySun" - 
    79 ‘... at 400 xSun,-600 ySun’ ;  ‘... at 45W60N’ 
     76                    * eg, "200 arcsec patch centered on AR10943" vs. "200 arcsec wide by 400 arcsec high centered on ... " 
     77                    * ... "centered on 400 xSun,-600 ySun" vs  "centered on 45W60N" 
    8078 
    8179                *       If using reduced resolution images 
    … …  
    8987 
    9088*       Have I acknowledged software and tools used ... 
    91         *       to find & obtain data (HEK, VSO, EGSO, !AstroGrid, Solar Monitor, etc.) 
     89        *       to find & obtain data (HEK, VSO, HELIO, !AstroGrid, Solar Monitor, etc.) 
    9290        *       to visualize data (Helioviewer, JHelioviewer, !SolarWeather Browser, etc.) 
    9391        *       to process the data (SolarSoft, PDL, !SunPy, IRAF, etc.) 
    … …  
    10199 
    102100*       Is the data available for others to review? 
    103         *       Is the data available from an archive online, or have I included it for submission as a suplement to the article 
    104         *       If I have significantly processed the data, have I included my data for submission as a suplement to the article? 
     101        *       Is the data available from an archive online, or have I included it for submission as a suplement to the article? 
     102        *       If I have significantly processed the data, have I included my processed data for submission as a suplement to the article or to an appropriate archive for distribution? 
    105103 
    106104